Mafia #47 "Ghost Hunters"

[Opicana]

Opi, here is post #90,, where you stated: "he sounded a bit too confident in declaring who was evil, for only having day 1 info"

Maybe you should read the whole post.

Really it is simple math. It is not like there are lots of players. I am fairly certain that of the three players I was talking about (DD, Jpap, & Orge), one is evil and one has a power role. It is really not that much of a stretch. It is of course with the assumption that Lady G might have tweeked the roles a bit. Also I think that one could take any three players and make the same statement.

Saying I sounded "too confident" is really misleading. Referring to a post and not quoting is also real misleading.

There would be....2 evil people right now? At least that's what it seems like according to the rules. There are 12 people...so minus yourself...that's 11. I still think that saying with any kind of confidence that someone is "evil" is a little shady. It's just mho. We aren't talking about probabilities here...we are talking about accusations. It's shouldn't be taken lightly.

Misquoting someone is misleading...but I didn't paraphrase or misquote you. Listing the post # merely indicates either a) laziness or b) lack of time.

Considering you were on the bottom of my suspect list, I feel that your defense was a bit unnecessary. Besides, I thought you liked being a "suspect"?

My list still stands: DD, Rich, JL.

I'm not confident on ANY of the above...but day one votes are necessary. I am going to hold off voting til I get a response from DD about the "Rickets" comment. If she convinces me, then I will go with Rich.

 

[luckydud13]

I feel being a mafia suspect keeps the mafia off of me. Well that, and I do enjoy being evil.

And I feel that you openly saying that is both odd, and a sure way to try to draw attention away from yourself.

IF the mafia know you are the suspect ehy won't be on your case, but the townspeople will. If you lay low, you could be the mafia, or you could be a low count poster. Either way, there is evidence to prove that you could be associated with the mafia.


If you like being a suspect you should love this......
I vote to take the soul of Johnlarson66
So obviously John is at the top of my list, and Noodles is second.

 

[cjtabares]

Well i will not be able to get on later someone called out of one of my stores and i have to go back to work so i will place my vote right now. I don't have any strong suspects right now but after reading over the thread a few times i feel like rich has posted a few times and not said much about anything. Looks like he is trying to look active with out saying much. This may be a little weak but it is all i have to go on right now.
So I vote to take the soul of Rich.

 

[OgreMkV]

Wow, Pap! I'm very surprised to see you come out with your defense after just 1 vote for you. I wasn't really looking at you before but this has raised a red flag. I have to keep my eye on you.

I can also see JL and Ogre being mafia but right now JPap stands out the most to me.

This is kind of true, but he also had three other players say that they would like to vote him. Once you get that momentum on day 1, you're pretty much doomed.

I think that this day one has been slower than most I have played. I considered spicing it up with a ranked, numbered list that means nothing, but decided to lay off until at least day two for that. As of right now, JL, Ogre and DD are the only ones who I have any suspicions of, and I think that it's just because it's habit. I've learned not to trust them, especially JL and Ogre (who completely snowed me a few games back). I don;t think I've played with many of you before, so this should be fun!

**My thoughts are with you, Tib. Hope everything turns out well!**

Wait a minute, you were the one that snowed me!

And I feel that you openly saying that is both odd, and a sure way to try to draw attention away from yourself.

IF the mafia know you are the suspect ehy won't be on your case, but the townspeople will. If you lay low, you could be the mafia, or you could be a low count poster. Either way, there is evidence to prove that you could be associated with the mafia.

If you like being a suspect you should love this......
I vote to take the soul of Johnlarson66
So obviously John is at the top of my list, and Noodles is second.

I don't know whether to agree or disagree with this. I definately agree with the sentiment, but the statement in red sounds too much like Ice. He tends to do the 'damned if you do and damned if you don't' comments as well... of course John had to give Lucky the ammo to say this so there might be something there.

Lucky, why is noodles second?

Well i will not be able to get on later someone called out of one of my stores and i have to go back to work so i will place my vote right now. I don't have any strong suspects right now but after reading over the thread a few times i feel like rich has posted a few times and not said much about anything. Looks like he is trying to look active with out saying much. This may be a little weak but it is all i have to go on right now.
So I vote to take the soul of Rich.

Man, that was gonna be my vote.

Just for now and unless something weird happens I vote to take the soul of Rickets

This is just a general feeling of unease and some comments (like the quote above).

 

[rich311k]

Got votes on the first day. i must be getting better at this. It is the shifty eyes and the slightly larger than normal paunch isn't it?

I only have my day one, activity theory about John to go on so I vote to take the soul of Johnlarson66.

The way first days go I may change it as I should be around before night fall.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

best wishes to Tibs....

not sure Rickets, but the more you go on about Pappy, the more it looks like you are doing so on purpose... and in my opinion, is making you more suspicious... my vote is going your way or Paps...

The more I go on about Pappy? I made 1 post about Pappy. Send a vote my way if you like. Since your post DD, now I have narrowed it down to 2, you or Pappy. DD you weren't on my radar either if you go back and look. This comment which is out of the blue and way off base is throwing me. I want to see something more from you on this accusation DD and I would like to hear from Pappy again too.

For now I vote to take the soul of DD...obviously I am also willing to vote for Pappy but DD has peaked my interest.

 

[IceH2O]

I like the fact that after I voted Jpap no one followed but some people responded.


I don't really grasp why DD attacked Rickets in that post. One post does not equate to relentless attacking of Jpap.Seems to me that 1 of 3 things is happening here.

1. Jpap is the murderer and DD is trying to deflect off him to Rickets.

2. DD is trying to buy a friend by saving an innocent Jpap.

3. DD is innocent,in game only lol, and is as lost as the rest of us.


Now I'm not sure I believe 3 at all. I think DD has been pretty aggressive with her few posts.
I don't know if I want to pull off Jpap and vote DD because I'd hate to let the murderer slip through my fingers. But I think I'm more sure of DD.

Someone I think Opi said 2 evils. Its in fact 3 as they started with 2 and claimed one the 1st night.

 

[IceH2O]

My comp is freaking out!

Ok lets try again

I retract my vote for Jpap and vote to take the soul of DD

 

[Opicana]

Now I'm not sure I believe 3 at all. I think DD has been pretty aggressive with her few posts.
I don't know if I want to pull off Jpap and vote DD because I'd hate to let the murderer slip through my fingers. But I think I'm more sure of DD.

Someone I think Opi said 2 evils. Its in fact 3 as they started with 2 and claimed one the 1st night.

Really? Huh....totally not how I read that. Hmm....in that case, JL's claim was a bit more reasonable. Though, I am still not okay with declaring anyone as evil just yet.

With that said...I still need to make a vote. Not sure how much time I will have between now and nightfall. So, just in case, I will throw my vote out now, but I may still retract it.

Sorry, DD, but I vote to take the soul of DangerDoll.

As you can see from my previous list, she was my number 1 suspect, primarily because of the jump on Rickets. However, I am not absolutely confident in this...I still may switch to Rich later.

 

[johnlarson66]

Opi, I also said that one is a power role. You seemed to have missed that part.

My choice of those three has nothing based on how they are playing or anything besides odds and the assumption that Lady G tweaked the roles.

I am curious of how DD will act with a few votes on her.

Someone has to go tonight. I like the games where players can comeback from being lynched. I know at times I feel bad for voting someone out in the first day because the game is just getting started. Sometimes it is a compliment to be gone on the first day (or night).

I am more comfortable with my vote on DD and have no plans on changing it. I wonder if it is close if she will OMGUS me to keep it even more close.