RO/DI Filter Suggestions

First, I'd try to find someone that has a TDS meter (Total Dissolved Solids) and check what the TDS level is in your tap water. If you can't find someone with one, you could always pick one up online for roughly $20 before s/h (check eBay if need be -- the Hanna ones are decent). It's a good idea to have one anyways, since it'll tell you when your RO and/or DI are spent / not working properly. If you don't want to buy a TDS meter and can't find anyone with one, you should be able to obtain a water quality report from the city you live in that has what it is leaving their facility (if you have city water). Granted, it's difficult to tell how much TDS is added between there and your home, but it's a number to start with.

If you have low TDS in your tap water, you could very easily go with strictly a DI unit without too many problems or frequent effort regenerating the spent DI resin beds. Otherwise, the time / effort needed to maintain a straight DI unit might not be worth it.

There is no benefit or consequence to water quality using just DI over a RO/DI unit. The RO membrane simply removes 90%+ of the impurities before they can reach the DI stage, prolonging the life of the DI resin. This is why the DI chamber on a RO/DI unit is only 10" (or smaller), while each chambers of a DI only unit are typically much larger.

If you are concerned about wastewater quantities with a RO or RO/DI unit, there are couple things you can do...
1) Be sure tap water pressure and temperature are as close to the ideal range as possible (if not stated in the info that comes with a particular unit, should be easy to locate online). Low water pressures will require a booster pump to increase efficiency. Low water temperatures are a bit more risky to play with -- if the temp gets too high, the membrane can be damaged and even melt (again, operating temp / max operating temp should be easy enough to find online). There are safe ways to help raise tap water temp, but they may not be all that effective in a basement setting. Fixing problems related to low pressure and temp will help improve efficiency, but waste to product ratio is still likely to be close to 3:1 - 4:1.

2) Look into purchasing a RO/DI unit with dual RO membranes, such as this one:
http://www.thefilterguys.biz/water_saver_ro_di.htm
There's info on that site about how it works, so I won't retype what's already there. In short, it drastically reduces the amount of wastewater being generated. While I realize this unit alone is at the top of your price range, if the cost of tap water is an issue, it could be a smart choice with the water savings alone versus a single membrane RO/DI making the added initial cost well worth it.

I use water jugs that are readily available at any sporting goods store that sells camping equipment to store / move RO/DI water. The ones I have hold 7g each and cost about $6 each. I would never attempt to pour water from them directly into any tank, especially when the jugs are full, as lifting and carefully pouring 7g up at shoulder level is just not fun for me. I mix saltwater in a 5g bucket, then pump the sw (usually after it's been stored for a week or more) into our tank with a Maxi-Jet and some vinyl tubing.
 
I know its an endless debate; but are you're sure you REALLY need ro/di water for a FOWLR tank? This topic is controversial and I'm one who uses treated tap water.(I'm almost afraid to come out of the closet) I have for years and have never had a problem that I would blame on my water source. It depends on your local water supply. Get a report from your water company that tells you what is in the water-they are required to give you one. Phosphates are very easy to remove, using various products. Copper plumbing can be a problem.Try posting a thread asking for people who use tap water and watch the response.
 
I am actually wanting to avoid using RO/DI because I have no place for the filter right now and I have no place around that sells it. I just IMed somebody for an opinion on that subject. What type of conditioner are you using mrtuskfish? I have a Fluval 405 filter. I'm thinking about replacing the carbon with Elite Chemi Pure and maybe getting a phosphate reactor if nessesary. I use API Stress Coat water conditioner for my freshwater tank. It doesn't say anything on the bottle about wether or not it is ok for saltwater so I'm not sure if I want to use this brand or not.
 
The R/O-D/I systems that DarkSoul posted are excellent and really priced low compared to most.If you put a valve on your wastewater line it will decrease your wastewater by tons,the only downside is you will use up the membrane faster because it forces more water through it,(from what I have read).I have used mine before with the valve almost closed(about 1 to 1 ratio)it will save a ton of $ on your water bill.Then use the waste water to wash clothes or your dog ,water plants,take a bath ect.If your only talking about 10 gallons a week or so,I'm sure you can find a good use for it.How much is water there per gallon?Here it is about 2 cents a gallon.I can not imagine it being more than 10 cents there,so your only talking 1 dollar for 10 gallons of waste water a week,And the perks from using R/O water are well worth an extra couple dollars you will spend each week on your water bill.Believe me you will have nothing but problems with tap water.I dont care how much stress coat you add it doesnt remove nitrates and phosphates or the metals in tap water.It only removes chlorine and helps relieve stress on your fish by replenishing their slime coat.Stress Coat is good but it doesnt work miracles.I used tap water for years too,using only AquaSafe water conditioner but when I changed to R/O-D/I water my water quality has vastly improved and your fish and corals(which you will eventually want) will surely appreciate it too.
 
Last edited:
I am actually wanting to avoid using RO/DI because I have no place for the filter right now and I have no place around that sells it. I just IMed somebody for an opinion on that subject. What type of conditioner are you using mrtuskfish? I have a Fluval 405 filter. I'm thinking about replacing the carbon with Elite Chemi Pure and maybe getting a phosphate reactor if nessesary. I use API Stress Coat water conditioner for my freshwater tank. It doesn't say anything on the bottle about wether or not it is ok for saltwater so I'm not sure if I want to use this brand or not.
My comments about tap water are referring to FOWLR tanks. I have not kept coral, or other inverts since relocating after being blown away by Katrina. I did keep a very nice reef tank in Mississippi, using tap water, for years. Stress Coat is a good product; LFSs often put a bit in the bag with your fish. But, I think, Stress Coat will cause your skimmer to go nuts- because it has ingredients to help the fish's slime coat.(Slime coat is protein, skimmers remove protein). I use "Prime", made by Sea Chem, and there are other good conditioners on the market. Check what it does online, I know Drs Foster&Smith have it. Sea-Chem also has a good web site & tech support. If I remember (I have some, but not in the original bottle) it does say something about helping slime coats, but doesn't effect skimmers. I sure am not trying to knock RO/DI water; but I just don't think everyone needs it. Make your own,informed decision.
 
AquariaCentral.com