German Blue Ram Eggs & Breeding

So I got home this afternoon and looked at the eggs and they looked almost deflated???? The male was still over top of them watching so I don't understand what's happening or what had happened while I was gone. In some of the eggs they have a little white dot? Any ideas???
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wild West
Not sure if this applies....My SA chichlid eggs would turn more oval before sprouting tails. Or, if the white has spread, they may not be viable. Some of my fish, I could use a flashlight to see the glow of the eyeballs forming in the eggs before hatching, see any of that?

If you are certain its actually a male and female (not two females, sorry not familiar with rams), could the water current be too strong and washing the silt away?
 
Unfortunately, Wild West, the eggs died last night and the male gave up guarding them... I determined the pH and water hardness was way too high and am currently lowering the pH with it now being a 7.4 compared to the previous 8.2. I hope for them to give it another go within the next couple weeks, the male is already starting to bother the female into breeding again :) I am positive that they are both a male and female due to behavioral and physical observations
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wild West
How are you lowering the pH? I wouldn't recommend using something like pH down as it just starts a roller coaster effect and that's more harmful to fish than a high pH that is constant.
What is the pH out of your tap?
What are your other water parameters?
What is your maintenance schedule?
All of these will factor into your pH in order to find the source of the increased levels.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wild West
I am currently going to be doing 5 gallon water changes with ro water adding a recommended amount of acid and alkaline buffer from a local aquarium store owner to lower my ph slowly. The ph of my tap is 8.4, and in my tank everything else is good (ammonia 0, nitrates 0, etc.) I scrub the tank once a week to remove the algae of the walls and do once a month 25-45% water changes and tank cleaning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wild West
I'm concerned that your nitrates are zero, that seems strange for an established tank. Once a month of 25% is probly not frequent enough of a change to be keeping nitrates that low unless the tank is HEAVILY planted, hardly fed and extremely understocked.
Personally, I doubt the pH is the reason for the egg death. But if you have the experience/help to lower it slowly and keep it constant I can't see it hurting. Especially since rams prefer softer, more acidic water.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wild West
Depending on how fast it dropped from 8.2 to 7.4 that could be too quick. Remember that pH is a log scale, so a little move is really MUCH MUCH more
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wild West
I'm sorry it wasn't my nitrates zero I was mistaken. I'll be doing a couple more water changes within the next couple of weeks to help lower it, that's what I was told to do. The only thing I can think of for the egg death is the ph because none of the other fish were eating or bothering them and they looked fine but not all were fertile.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wild West
I do realize that it's a big drop, but this far my fish still seem happy healthy eating and swimming great so I'll give it some more time
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wild West
AquariaCentral.com