Free trees for Earth Day...what are your thoughts?

platytudes

AC Members
Nov 4, 2006
3,450
0
36
Panama City, FL
Real Name
Nicole
Tomorrow is Earth Day...there are a number of places nearby that are giving away trees tomorrow (and over the weekend) in honor of it. One of them is Lowe's:
http://www.lowes.com/cd_Earth+Day_817240224_

They don't say what kind of tree they are giving away, but looking around online it looks like they are pine trees of some sort.

Comments abound such as, "Can't argue with free!" and "Hey, who cares what kind of tree it is...it's free!" and this seems to be the attitude I've noticed at other tree giveaway occasions.

Earth Day tree giveaways seem to me almost like carnival goldfish. I mean, who wants to accidentally end up with a tree that grows over 100' tall? (Leyland cypress and Sycamores are popular giveaway trees, and they exceed 100' at maturity.) Likewise, who wants to end up with a comet goldfish that will need a pond or 4-6' tank someday?

I can see how in a school setting, they could be used to teach children about the benefits of trees and the importance of conserving them (although most of them are a little too young to understand the concept of urban sprawl and the like).

However, it surprises me how many adults accept them, without any preparation, and how many responsible organizations give them out, almost like living pamphlets.

I would much rather people plant carefully chosen trees on a designated site (for example, school children planting select trees around their school) rather than take some home to do whatever with...

:huh:
 
Don't see how they hurt anything...100 ft tall specimens of those variety are very rare in most populated areas....
 
Would be nice to have a big ole pine in my back yard...
 
So you think it's a good thing for people to acquire a potentially very large tree on the spur of the moment, and accept it, simply because it's free? ;) Personally, I'd rather celebrate Earth Day with some thoughtful community activities ala Arbor Day Foundation, rather than make it a junk/swag event involving living things.
 
Yes, I do. For many yrs it will be helping exchange gasses, providing clean O2, and a living space for birds and other creatures. If 40-50 yrs from now it needs to be cut down for out growing the area, fine. It then can provide warmth thru firewood or be composted to help the soil. Arbor Day Foundation gives away trees all the time and never requires folks receiving them to go thru an authorization process for them. Think you are over doing it a bit here. I handed out over 3,000 trees last yr for Arbor Day.... and if a tenth of them live for a tenth of their expected lifetime, then that is a plus overall. And even the dead or dieing ones help.
 
Last edited:
I think it's a great idea... but I think most pines are ugly.

I'd rather spend $10-$20 on a nice small tree that looks nice than plant an ugly pine tree in my back yard... even if it is free.

(I'm a big fan of trees and I've bought many in my life at my various properties... wish I could go cut down all the pine on my property though... ugly things).
 
who cares? some whack-o enviromentalist will say it was too much...you know how studying those million yr old ice cores are so true...
 
Don't see how they hurt anything...100 ft tall specimens of those variety are very rare in most populated areas....

Ever lived in a house with a Sycamore overhanging it? They lose branches faster than you're losing your hair! And while the wood will burn, it's far from good for heating purposes. The bark is good as a firestarter though.
 
AquariaCentral.com