Dumb light question

Jag586

AC Members
May 29, 2012
96
0
0
42
This may sound dumb but I have a 200 gallon I want to make into a reef tank I'm trying to do it less expensive so can I hook up regular compact lights under my canopy to light up the reef? The new ones that sxrew into the socket and look like a twisted floresent bulb I'm doing soft corals so would 800 watts do it or is there a cheaper better way?

Sent from my LS670 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
I don't think those types of bulbs come in the right light spectrum and likely would pentrate poorly on the height of a 200g tank. If one had to go cheap I'd suggest looking into oddysea fixtures as long as you dont want SPS's. AFAIK PAR38's are the only decent screw in type reef bulbs.

My personal suggestion save up until you can afford a decent setup. Stick with FOWLR untill you can.
 
Last edited:
Well it wont be until next spring I'm going to buy a lil at a time that's why I kinda want a diy thing too...

Sent from my LS670 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Check out rapid led, if you're into DIY you can build a great setup. Regardless it's not going to be cheap to have reef capable lighting on that size tank. Building your own led fixtures is about the only way to go. You could get halides for cheaper up front, but the long run it'll be much cheaper to go LEDs.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
So research leds? Ok cool and about 800 watts is good or more less

Sent from my LS670 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
It isn't so much the spectrum or penetration with CFL's (although they do fall at the low end of both). It is the price scale.


When you are looking at small tanks, it works. A couple standard bases and some cheap bulbs and you are set. Much cheaper then a T5.

Then you scale things upwards. I can tell you that two CFL will cover a half-filled 40B, and will grow soft corals (never attempted LPS or SPS). But that is about the edge of it. And that is already approaching T5HO lighting for a 40B (a third bulb and the wattage evens out). Once you go past 4' and more then 18" tall, the array needed to adequately light the tank gets more expensive then other options. At 200 gallons it'd be cheaper to toss a MH or two or some T5's over top.

It'd work for fish-only. But for corals you have cheaper options.



Don't worry about wattage. At that size tank coverage will be your concern, and you'll get the required wattage simply by getting the required coverage.
 
I saw online not sure if it was this website but a guy had two t5 and like 3 or 4 mh think that might be my plan... but what's with the blue bulbs? Do they add a blue tinge to the tank for looks or is there a deeper reason for them I want to build the lights into my cover but its a 6 ft long tank.. maybe a couple 18 inch fluorescent on each end and couple spaced in middle with some mh in the spaces idk... I'm lost

Sent from my LS670 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
It is sort of a convergence of reasons.

The deeper you go in the ocean the more the light shifts toward blue. As such corals are adapted to absorb more in the blue spectrum with some taken in the red spectrum. Green is effectively wasted on them. Reef-keeping culture has a bit of an obsession with maximizing the usable light for their corals so they tend towards blue light with a peak in the red spectrum (which is often lost in the overpowering blue light). This has led to blue basically being the fashion of reef tanks. Just as 6700K is the fashion for planted tanks. It has become automatically assumed that reef lighting should tend toward blue, just as it is assumed that planted lighting should shift toward daylight. And it helps that corals flouresce in moon light, which tends heavily towards the blue. Meaning that many corals will look drastically better with heavy blue supplement (ie: actinic or royal blue LEDs).



A reef can run perfectly fine under daylight, just as a planted tank can run just fine under actinic. It may not run as efficient though, and the color may not be as nice, but it is perfectly doable.
 
Ok so I have these two lamps that use 300 watt t3 bulbs could I use those with say 4 18 inch fluorescent bulbs running front to back... say fluorescent bulb t3 two fluorescent bulbs t3 fluorescent bulb... maybe have the fluorescent bulbs the blue ones?

Sent from my LS670 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Ok so I have these two lamps that use 300 watt t3 bulbs could I use those with say 4 18 inch fluorescent bulbs running front to back... say fluorescent bulb t3 two fluorescent bulbs t3 fluorescent bulb... maybe have the fluorescent bulbs the blue ones?

Sent from my LS670 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

What are these 300 watt t3 bulbs?

You could make a setup like that with the 18" bulbs, but it's not going to be anywhere enough light, I have two on my biocube and it works fine, but on your size tank you're going to need a lot more.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
AquariaCentral.com