AquaClear 110 Polishing to Nitrate filter Mod 3

CWO4GUNNER

USN/USCG 1974-2004 Weps
Greetings AC filter owners, as some of you know I have another thread which brings us to the starting point of this thread where I previously split & stacked the AC 110 sponge to create a reservoir behind the sponge so that hydraulic water pressure is used to filter water over an area twice the size of the stock while also increasing performance.

I also added the mod of raping the front of the sponges with Polyester batten to see if polishing could be accomplished without the early clogging experienced with the stock configuration. Now having run the filter this way for 40 days non-stop this thread will show the results and proceed to the 3rd level modification the AC Nitrate Filter.

The Aqua-Tech HOB Nitrate filter was the prototype having used many plants have finally confirmed that the house plant Pothos is the fastest growing, lowest diseased, lowest light requirement, highest disease resistance, and lowest maintenance bare root plant for effective removal of Nitrates from the aquarium. My 60 gallon Oscar tank consistently having the highest nitrates before each water change, now has the lowest from 40 PPM to 10 PPM. Something that cannot be done by simply placing the plant roots in the aquarium itself or stagnant water as there must be a delivery system for all nutrients in the aquarium to continually pass by the root system many times per hour in order for nitrates to be introduced and absorbed by the plants bare roots system, converted nitrates into rapid plant growth.

So we start where we left off after 40 days of using the Polyester batten over the AC sponge filter with impressive but limited results. As you can plainly see the Polyester captured dirt that the sponge filter allowed to escape, however only the top half portion of the sponge and polyester caught any dirt while bypass occurred on the bottom half.
NitratefilterMod3003.jpg

NitratefilterMod3004.jpg

Bypass on the bottom occurred because of the AC basket grate holes in the front and sides that limit the 6 straws ability to space the filter front in order that water can pass from the reservoir through the sponge, but in fact some water is bypassing from the first 2 rows of grate holes in the AC basket as you can see below.
NitratefilterMod3011.jpg

Even so the performance of the filter Mod has proven to be much better then stock configuration we can improve filtration further by blocking those first two rows of bypass holes eliminating all bypass on the bottom. I recommend that the time be taken to plug these grate holes using Silicone sealant however, since I like and have never had a problem using aluminum tape on my filter modification and to expedite this modification I will be using aluminum tape instead.
NitratefilterMod3013.jpg

Now as you can see below when the straws offset the front of the sponge with spacing to allow for water flow front to back ,no bypassing in any relative amount will occur and the bottom portion of the sponge will become inundated with dirt as well.
NitratefilterMod3015.jpg

You will note below the proof in that no water now passes out of the ends of the straws as occurred before without the grate hole blocking. So one could re-wrap the front in new polyester batten and expect greatly improved results for polishing however, for the next step in converting the AC filter to a nitrate filter we will use the naked sponge so that high water flow GPH will guarantee nutrients delivery to our bare root Pothos plant insert.
NitratefilterMod3016.jpg

We start with our $5 potted Pothos house plant from Lowes. Normally in summer the outside hose water is warn enough to wash off the bare roots but because of winter temps we must do this in the bathtub with buckets to wash off the soil with warm 80F water and dump the soil outside.
NitratefilterMod3020.jpg

NitratefilterMod3023.jpg

NitratefilterMod3025.jpg

Now further wash and separate the individual root stocks by size so that you use the larger to smaller, placing them at the location near your HOB for installation.
NitratefilterMod3028.jpg

NitratefilterMod3037.jpg

You will need a cheap waxed dental floss to hang the plants stocks inside and over the HOB reservoir and 1” finisher nails to secure the dental floss to the drywall and a small hammer to drive the nails into the drywall at a 20 degree angle.
NitratefilterMod3029.jpg

NitratefilterMod3035.jpg

Use a slip knot in the dental floss so that you can adjust the size of the look over the tallest leaf stock and so that the slip knot will self adjust as the plant grows not cutting off circulation. The dental floss should be long enough to reach the nail with plenty of slack to rap around the nail several times (NOT TIE) for later adjustment (shorten or lengthen ) as needed.
NitratefilterMod3033.jpg

Arrange each plant starting from the center with the largest stock working your way out on each side of the HOB reservoir using 1 nail to tie two stocks up at a time. Make sure the roots lay inside the reservoir just under the water line with the filter shut off (no water flowing yet). If adjustment is needed simply unravel the slack at the nail just like re-tying a boat line to a pier cleat.
NitratefilterMod3032.jpg

NitratefilterMod3036.jpg

That’s it, turn on the filter, adjust root line underwater as necessary. Pothos will grow with ambient room and distant window light but recommend augmentation by flipping your 18-24 Watt fixture on its side for at least 4 hours a day. DO NOT use incandescent or hot lights as it will fry the plant. Plant should start removing nitrates after initial transplant shock in 2 weeks, be patient and you will see great results.
May the Father of lights grant you a blessed Christmas.
NitratefilterMod3038.jpg

nitrate4001-1.jpg

 
Very impressive. I'm teed up for a possible no3 surge for some of my tanks, so I might give your mod a try.

I'm not the best at DIY though....what kind of benefit do you think one would derive from just rooting some plants in a standard-operated AC?
 
Well if you look at my other AC mod threads you'll see that the AC by design, that is to say its media configuration is inherently flawed IMO. The stock design set the media up to block work against the pump with its wight and not utilize any hydraulic advantage, stock it also does not take advantage of the full surface area potential of the filter box. The ratio of surface area must always must always take priority over volume to have decent efficiency.

So all the basic mod does us stack the media on its side so that a low pressure reservoir is created in back. This allows the AC pump to work freely without back pressure, then uses the wight of hydraulic pressure (reservoir body of water to push itself through a greater surface are (2X) which means lower restriction but better filtering. Also water will never back up and float the media over the container sides becasue water is pushing back to front not bottom to top.

This is why all modern HOB's use this exact method. For the AC 110 you simply saw the stock sponge length wise in half with a bread knife, go slow and work from all sides and it will cut even and strait giving you two halves to stack. The AC 70 there is not sponge cutting, you simple use two sponges stacked on their sides. So simple a cave man could do it.

The rest of the mods like the Poly Rap and Nitrate filter are also simple. The end result is a much lower maintenance and effectively cleaning filter depending upon if you want better mechanical or nitrate filtering capability.

Remember these mods do not change the filter itself, just a $4 sponge and use of a house plant. Its not like we are cutting up hardware, its all software mods. Even if you mess up the sponge and plan all you have to do is stick the two end back together in the old configuration and re-pot the plant and you have the same old filter as before, letting you know when the filter is dirty in just a week by popping up the media, the lid off and getting the dry wall wet.

But to answer your question in the stock configuration the plants would be pushed off the top of the media in a week and end up falling out of the filter becasue there is no lid to strap down with a belt or a brick to place on top, as is the normal stock routine.

Very Respectfully;)
 
Last edited:
very creative way of polishing the water- that is what I would love to try this weekend modifying all of my filters-

My question is

is there a website we can refer to to find out which plants/roots are basically safe?
 
Thanks for the response, C-4-G....I have AC's on all 3 of my tanks, so I'm definitely going to put your mod on my "to-do" list. :)
 
very creative way of polishing the water- that is what I would love to try this weekend modifying all of my filters-

My question is

is there a website we can refer to to find out which plants/roots are basically safe?

Yes that is it first the thread that got too long. If you do set one up for polishing as per my mod instructions please let me know if you encounter any issues as I from experiences probubly have worked out the quick fix. Oh and as far as being able to use other media like rings or carbon, as long as you are willing to re-bag them by emptying some out 1/2 and sewing up the lose material with dental floss and a needle, you should be able to stack one as well as long as you maintain the reservoir.
 
Thanks for the response, C-4-G....I have AC's on all 3 of my tanks, so I'm definitely going to put your mod on my "to-do" list. :)

Well if there is room for improvement why not. Personally I have only used HOB as a augmenting filter and never had as much nearly as much performance from them as a primary filter. But where I have learned they truly shine is for low cost but effective nitrate filtration.

As far as a list of plants I have looked and all I could find were recommendations on what to use. The most proliferate plant I have seen used bare root successfully is Pothos and I can tell you after having mine up and running now since October 16th and have had no problems with my 2 messy 7" Oscars and 1 messy 6" Electric blue. It does take about 4 weeks before the plant becomes established and starts sucking out nitrates noticeably. I almost gave up myself a few weeks ago but suddenly I noticed a big change coinciding with the plants new growth. http://www.aquariacentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=208931

Read up on Pothos and you'll find that it is the most successful low light fastest growing amazon jungle plant on the planet and very efficient at filtering the air we breath in doors removing a host of toxins just like its roots in the water.

A quote from aquarium fish.net: "An awesome idea that I got from the National Aquarium in Baltimore is using Scindapsus aureus, better known as Golden Pothos or Devil's Ivy as a living filter, hiding place and whatever else it happens to work as. If one cuts several branches of that ubiquitous plant that seems to proliferate in every house, school and office, and floats them in an aquarium, very quickly the branches convert their little bumps of air roots into a tangled mass of water roots and start growing like crazy. Fish love it: the pesky digger angelfish spends the night sitting in the roots. I have the branches dangling over the edge of the tank. In just about three weeks, the branches added almost a foot to their length and the roots have reached the sand on the bottom and are in the process of digging in." (http://www.****************/pages/submitted_feedback_page_55.htm)


 
Last edited:
Way cool Gunner. I did have one caution though for folks looking for plants. The pothos that you used looks very similar, almost identical, to a variegated philodendron that we have. The philodendron will also grow non-terrestially, I believe that it is the plants preference, but the issue with them is that there are many different varieties and many of them create nectars that are irritants to some and poisonous to many pets. What effect they would have on fish I couldn't speak to but the idea is that you only use the pothos plant when you can obtain it from a source where it is labeled. Don't rely on a visual I.D. unless you're a botanist or someone who really knows his stuff.

I'll try to get a pic later to better illustrate what I'm rambling about.
 
AquariaCentral.com