My PetSmart isn't bad as well. Good selection, good prices, good fish. My Petco isn't very good though.
the seems to be the overall consensus. Though i did suck it up and buy 15 rummies from petco. They were .99 and the cheapest aside from that was 2.99. Saved me $30 and only 1 died. They are the most colorful rummies i've seen.