20 Long Tang Tank

i would hold off till you get a big tank, they need good water quality and they do grow slow, but not as slow as i thought, my friends where 5 inches in 2 years so... still pretty slow
 
I have no problem keeping water conditions good.

Bah but it looks like no calvus for me. The more I look into tangs the more I realize I would need a much larger tank than I have to keep some.

I'll just look into a freshwater community instead.
 
Bah but it looks like no calvus for me.

I hear you on that :) I had calvus fever for a while and almost convinced myself to put them in a tank with CA cichlids....

I think a 20g long is a great size for a planted community -- so easy to reach in and tweak the plants / decor to get exactly the look you want.

Enjoy!
 
nope dwarf puffers don't - better off in pure freshwater - its the hardness I am not sure about - they don't mind it quite close to concrete though, I think. I looked at them once myself but decided I didn't have room for the tank. Very cool lil fish - not sure on stocking levels though....something like 3 or 4 US Gallons per fish I think...you could maybe only have 1 or 2 in there if that's right.

edit I think in a 20 Long you could start with 3 - they get pretty nasty as they mature though so you may end up taking a couple back...have some plants in there and one or two cute as all get out lil dwarf puffer...and some snails. Check on that hardness though...but I think you could put in some driftwood and be fine.
 
Are you TRYING to be difficult on accident? Or at least make it seem like an accident..... :D

20L would make a great shellie tank but like you I was not impressed with them...at first. They are definitely growing on me though, I keep wandering towards them at the LFS.

I REALLY want to setup an open top planted 20L, so you should do that to help my addition, ok? :D That would be my vote based on your responses here, plus they are so easy to work in!
 
Wow, 5 inches in 2 years for Calvus? What are you feeding them? My female is 2 years old and roughly 2 inches long. My male is around 3, 3-1/2, and 4 inches. My other male is about 2 1/2- 3 years and roughly 3 inches.
I wouldn't see a problem with a pair in a 20 long for several years if bought as juvies. Provided you add enough rock-work you could probably keep a J. Transcriptus as well. A 40 breeder would make a good breeding tank for the Calvus as they grow out down the road.
 
AquariaCentral.com