Pleco Alternative?

hforney

AC Members
Nov 24, 2004
62
0
0
Since plecos grow so large what is a good alternative for a 55g tank. I am just starting to add fish and going thru the cycling process. I will have a planted tank with small peaceful community fish. What type of fish would take care of algae on driftwood, plants, and aquarium glass.

Thanks in advance, (a newbie here)
 
mayreee said:
What about a small pleco like a bristlenose, some ottos, or a chinese alge eater?

How large will they grow? I had a 29g 5 years ago and the pleco grew so large he destroyed my tank.
 
mayreee said:
What about a small pleco like a bristlenose, some ottos, or a chinese alge eater?


DEFINITELY no on the chinese algae eater. As they mature, they eat less and less algae and get more and more aggressive.

Ottos are fine, but you'll need a couple for a 55 gallon...Also, if you're stocking large or aggressive fish, Ottos may be eaten since they grow to a maximum of 2 inches to about 2.5 inches.

Bristlenoses, I don't think that these should be a problem.

DEFINITELY don't get the chinese or siamese algae eaters.
 
Oddball and Mayreee, Thanks! I think I will look into the ottos as the fish I will be adding do not grow more than 2 inches.

Thanks to both!
 
Last edited:
I second (third?) the bristlenose. I adore mine; he's industrious, doesn't eat the plants, and he's very visible - out all the time during the day cleaning algae and hunting for food bits. He's a little cutie :D
A group of otos will also do a great job cleaning up, but if you're looking for personality I'd go with a bristlenose.
 
How large will the bristlenose grow? Will one bristlenose handle a 55g tank. Should I expect any problems with a bristlenose being in the tank with fish as small as neon tetras?

Thanks!

Blinky, I remember you answering a few other questions I posted on this forum. You are a great help to people like myself who just don't have answers.
 
It is uncommon for the Bristlenose to be out in the light. It might be you have not provided it with what it needs. A cave or something to burrow under. I have found, when provided with one, they are very industrious at removing algea in the dark.

If you get hair algea, I would suggest common platies and or rosey barbs. You need to keep in mind the rosies will pick on some stem plants if they run out of algea. But if well fed otherwise, not a problem.. In fact many of the small barbs wil eat hair algea. Rosey barbs will also eat small snails if they become a problem

Another small alternative to the brisltenose might be the Clown pleco -- Peckoltia vittata. It gets to about 4 inches max and hides a lot.. a couple in a 55 do nicely. Also Otocinclus is a good peaceful choice, I would say one per 10 gallons.

If you are making a plant tank out of it, keep in mind algea usually will not grow on actively growing leaves unless the tank is understocked with plants to begin with.

Gosh.. I seem to be full of it tonight.

Anchor
 
Clowns aren't known for cleaning up algae the way bristlenoses do - they are cute as a button though :D
anxsar - my little guy is positively spoiled ;) He's probably brave because he's in a heavily planted tank with a dark substrate, and has many hiding places to choose from (and no competition). He was a little chicken for the first week, and once he discovered that he could easily be the boss he relaxed. When the nightly wafer falls from the sky, he's the first one on it and he defends it as though it's his last meal! During the day, he cruises around cleaning the glass and chewing away at his driftwood. He does rest in the driftwood holes and his favourite spot under one part of the wood near the substrate, but I like that he's visible much of the time too. I know that some fish are naturally more or less shy than others - I think my guy may just be exceptionally brave.
hforney - aw, shucks! Seriously, that's what I love about AC - I can share what I know and learn new things from others :D
 
AquariaCentral.com