cycling a 3 gallon tank

I have a 2.5 gallon tank with that nano red sea filter on it. No problems what so ever. I also have an Eclipse 3 and 6 with bettas in them who are also fine with the current being put off. So long as you give them places to rest I see no issue with it and my bettas seem perfectly happy.
 
those are the wild bettas with the short fins(easier to scoot around with)
domesticated bettas are the ones who dont like current

also about the filter ,there are redsea nano filters that filter up to 3 gallons so that should work pretty well.

My domesticated beta loves the current in his 5 gallon home.

It doesn't bother him a bit.

Every beta I've ever kept in a current that he or she has been properly acclimated to. They have all lived much longer than any beta I've had in a current free tank too.
 
Wow thanks for all the responses!!!

From extensive reading and speaking with other betta owners who have cycled small tanks (because it's a common thing for betta keepers to not use filters on nano tanks), it seems to be a general statement that you can cycle any body of water with or without help of any additional media, used matter or pre existing bacteria?
 
You can do it either way, but some ways are quicker and more stable than others. In my opinion a nano with a filter cycles quicker and is more resistant to mini-cycling when challenged (e.g. by decomposing food, adding a snail etc).
 
The beneficial bacteria need a current to thrive. You may be able to get some to live in the gravel, but without any current they will quickly use up whatever food (ammonia, nitrite) is near them.

I've tried several of the commercial bacteria cultures. All but one of them were of questionable value. Only Dr Tim's "One and Only" bacteria culture made a noticeable difference. It's relatively expensive (about $11 at Fosters and Smith), but it actually works. I fully cycled a canister filter in a week using it.
 
You can do it either way, but some ways are quicker and more stable than others. In my opinion a nano with a filter cycles quicker and is more resistant to mini-cycling when challenged (e.g. by decomposing food, adding a snail etc).

:iagree: Your betta will be much happier with a filter in the tank.
 
I'm sorry guys, guess i'm just stubborn but i wouldnt have a tank smaller than a 29. my betta Rufus lives in a well planted 55 and is all over the tank. as for current he plays in the overflow from the HOB
 
The bacteria will actually live any and everywhere regardless of there being a filter or not. All the bacteria need is a source of food (ammonia for the one strain, and nitrite for the other) and a place to live. I've actually had unfiltered betta bowls that were "cycled." I simply avoided any scrubbing on the inside during water changes and managed to maintain the colony well enough that I only had to change the water weekly just to keep it clean and remove the small amount of nitrate that resulted from the biological cycle. The water never showed any ammonia or nitrite even after the week - and then once I after I removed a betta (I really only kept the bowls for QT) I tested it just for fun - putting a drop of ammonia in every few days for almost a month, then tested the water - 0 ammonia, 0 nitrite, nitrate off the charts. A consistently active biological cycle in a 1g betta bowl with no filter, no substrate and no airstone. I gave this water to my house plants, who were probably thrilled at the nitrogen.

But that being said I would still always recommend a good filter. And no, you don't need to seed it unless you want to jumpstart. With the fishless cycle you'll get the bacteria naturally over time. Some cycles take longer than others - and make sure that you never add any chlorine to the system with water changes - a system that is just getting started will be killed almost immediately with even the slightest amount of chlorine.

Just add the ammonia every few days - a very small but steady amount. Wait a few weeks before even trying to test it. With luck you'll see the ammonia gone and nitrite appearing or maybe even also gone with nitrate appearing...
 
Excellent! You actually did an experiment. I love it. And I stand corrected.
 
I must agree with bushwhacker. My betta males live in a 45 gallon endler tank and a 120 gallon community tank. Both are over 5 years old, play in the filter flows and are quite the social animals. There is no good reason to baby a Betta splendens male in good health. I feel that it is cruel to place a single fish in a 5 gallon tank by himself and expect him to have a decent life experience. I do attribute more human emotions to my fish than is probably justified but who needs a hermit lifestyle?
 
AquariaCentral.com